Top 5 Scar Creams

What scar treatment took home the editor’s choice award? We understand how uncomfortable scars can be to live with, so to help you get rid of your scars we listed our top 5 scar treatments. To come up with our top treatments, we evaluated scores of scar treatment options, from over the counter to all natural products. We listed them here in order of superiority and based our research on the following criteria:
  • 1. Effectiveness
  • 2. Speed of Results
  • 3. Quality of Ingredients
  • 4. Product Safety
  • 5. Customer Service
  • 6. Customer Feedback
  • 7. Reorder Rate
  • 8. Return Policy
  • 9. Success Rate
Top 5 Scars Scarinex Review Talsyn-CI Review Revitol-review
Best Scar Treatments More Info
Talsyn-CI More Info
More Info
Revitol More Info
H-Scars More Info
Price (1 bottle)
Price (4 bottles)*
(*best value)
Overall Rating: 99.3% 81.2% 78.6% 75.4% 68.7%
Effectiveness scar stars scar stars scar stars scar stars scar stars
Speed of Results Fastest Fast Average Average Slow
Ingredients Quality Superior Good Good ok ok
Product Safety Safe to Use Safe to Use Safe to Use Safe to Use Safe to Use
Customer Service scar stars scar stars scar stars scar stars scar stars
Customer Satisfaction 97.9% 80.5% 77.5% 74.2% 67.5%
Reorder Rate Highest Good Good Good Average
Return Policy Risk Free Risk Free Risk Free Restock Fee Risk Free
Success Rate 97.5% 74.2% 67.2% 65.7% 60.5%

Review of Scar Treatments:

Best Scar Treatments (in priority order):

#1 Scarinex (More Information)

Scarinex Scar Treatment Review

More Info

Approval Rating: 98.4% (product & cost comparison)

Product Claims:  

Scarinex is formulated with highly effective ingredients which have been researched and proven to reduce and eliminate scars.  Scarinex’s main product is a gel which uses 5 types of 100% Pure Medical Grade Silicone, the same as used by most medical professionals and plastic surgeons for scar removal.

Scarinex’s effectiveness is due to its powerful ingredients. Each ingredient has been individually reviewed by external sources to pinpoint the benefits of Scarinex.  This product is doctor endorsed and its ingredients have well over 50 case studies showing its effectiveness in removing scar tissue.

Scarinex sells two products on its website. Its main product, the scar removal gel and a product to help with skin rejuvenation. The Scar Gel helps decrease redness, swelling and pain while working to eliminate the scar.  It keeps in moisture for maximum skin repair.  The rejuvinator nourishes the skin and rebuilds the tissue supporting the scar gel.

Scarinex is formulated to work on different types of scars including:  acne, surgery, burn, hypertrophic, keloids, stretch marks, surgery scars and more.

Scarinex is formulated in a laboratory in the United States that is FDA-approved and GMP certified, which is held to strict quality standards. There is no unwanted side effect caused by scarinex, and it has been found safe for use by both men and women of any age. Scar sufferers can feel confident in this scar remover as it boasts a 100% money back guarantee.


The real value of Scarinex is in the package deals. Scarinex offers 2 bottles free if you order 2 bottles, which comes to $24.95 a bottle for 4 bottles. They have additional discounts if you buy 3 and get 3 free as well for even less per bottle. For $24.95 a treatment and guaranteed results, you cannot find a better deal. And Scarinex offers a 60 day guarantee for your money back if you are not satisfied with the product.

Our Conclusion:

Scarinex is the most effective scar removal treatment on the market. Consumers reported that it is very effective and has a very high rate of positive feedback. Scarinex’s price is affordable and customers report that it works.

#2 Talsyn-CI (More Information)

Approval Rating: 81.2%

Product Claims:

This product is a good product for reducing surgical, keloid and hypertrophic scars.  It feel to our #2 spot because it doesn’t treat the wide range of scars that our top product treats.  Talsyn-CI is endorsed by a Doctor and can improve the appearance and redness of scars, but consumer reviews state that it only fades scarring.

Talsyn-CI contains a Lipid – Peptide compound and blend of fatty acids, peptide and botanical extracts that help nourish healing incisions and attract collagen to the area and rebuild healthy tissue.  This product is best if used as early as possible in the healing cycle.  Older scars only show a reduction of 62%.  Our top product works on any scars new or old with the same effectiveness.

This product is safe and all-natural with only a noted side effect of possible redness.  It is recommended to use this product for 9 to 12 weeks consistently twice daily for improvement.  This product must be obtained from a physician and cannot be purchased directly on the Internet.  Our number one product is available to everyone and can be obtained on the Internet.


Talsyn-CI retails for $39.95 a tube and $159.80 for four tubes.  The four bottle deal offers no discount.  The manufacturer recommends more than one tube for larger scars.  This could really add up with the time it takes for his product to show effectiveness.

Our Conclusion:

Talsyn-CI contains some good ingredients to help nourish the skin and reduce scarring.  It falls short of our top product because it does not contain as many botanicals, takes longer to work and must be purchased from a physician.

#3 Kelo-cote (More Information)

Approval Rating: 78.6%

Product Claims:

Kelo-cote makes good use of a bio-inert and bio-compatible silicone compound designed to flatten, soften and smooth scars and assist with healing.  It falls short of our top product because it contains less ingredients that focus on actual tissue regeneration.

This product is designed to create a waterproof but breathable layer over the scar, this helps to soften, flatten and smooth the scar, while maintaining moisture and elasticity of the skin.  Kelo-cote is the only 100% silicone gel and was scientifically found to smooth out scars on any life form.  Still, it lacks more ingredients that increase moisture to wounds and aids in actual tissue regeneration. In addition, only 24% of patients rated its efficacy as very good.

Kelo-cote creates a protective barrier on the skin using Polysiloxanes – a long chain polymer which forms a waterproof semi-occlusive layer.  Even with a quality ingredient, this product still falls short of our top product.


Kelo-cote retails for $37.99 a tube and $109.99 for the equivalent of four tubes.  The manufacturer states it takes about 2-3 months to see the effectiveness of the product.

Our Conclusion:

Kelo-cote is a good product to help with skin repair.  This product did not cover as many types of scars as our top product did.

#4 Revitol (More Information)

Approval Rating: 75.4%

Product Claims:

Revitol is a good all-natural product that contains ingredients that can help with skin rejuvenation.  It fell short of our top product because it only has very little to help the body increase collagen production, increase moisture and heal scars.

This product has 100% all-natural and safe ingredients and helps reduce acne scars, burn scars, injuries and surgical scars without chemicals.  Our number one product covers all types of scars without chemicals and with more ingredients to protect and nourish the skin.

While the makes of this product state that it helps to fade most scarring, the results were not as dramatic as our top product.  The manufacturer states that this product is effective with 2 to 6 months of twice daily application.  Reviews of our number one product state the product begins to work in weeks.


This product retails for $49.95 for one bottle and $149.90 for four bottles.  This is definitely more costly than our number one product and if it needs to be used for more than just a few months could cost the consumer a great deal, for considerably less than our top product.

Our Conclusion:

With regular and long term use, Revitol is helpful for skin rejuvenation.  It fell to our #4 spot because it just did not have a good range of ingredients to cover more types of scars.  The value was also a bit pricey for our editors.

#5 H-Scars (More Information)

Approval Rating: 68.7%

Product Claims:

H-Scars is a good 100% all-natural and organic product for helping body reduce the appearance of scars.  This product fell to our #5 spot because it only has a few ingredients that can benefit the body and increase healing of the skin.  Our top product contains far more ingredients to help nourish the skin.

This product contains some good plant based essential oils that are all-natural and safe.  These oils can soften the skin and improve skin tone.  The skin needs far more to reduce the appearance of scarring and this product just didn’t quite measure up.  It does contain Immortelle – that can assist with cell regeneration and is a natural anti-inflammatory.  It also contains a few other herbs to nourish the skin.  Our top product contains far more herbs that can help nourish and repair the skin.

The blend in H-Scars is formulated to soften, moisturize and add tone to the skin.  This falls short of our top product that contains more to reduce the appearance of scars and nourish the skin.


H-Scars retails for a whopping $69.95 a bottle, considerably higher than our top product for far less ingredients.  The four bottle deal is $279.80.  Our editors felt that this product needed to offer consumers more ingredients or maybe a little bigger package for their money.

Our Conclusion:

This product is good for skin moisturizing and a small amount of skin regeneration, but it did not have enough ingredients to justify the cost of the product.  The manufacturer could add just a few more ingredients, create a better four bottle offer to put this one up the list.